I used to walk into a first conversation as if it were a blank page. It almost never is.
A surprising number of the people I meet are on their second attempt, or their third. They bought a system and nobody used it. They paid for a build that never went live. Someone before me billed a lot of hours and left them with something they still can't explain. They are polite about it, but it is in the room.
When I miss that, I do the wrong thing. I show something polished and get careful, quiet nods. I read the quiet as interest. Really they are waiting to see how I am different from the last person who showed them something polished.
So early on I ask what happened last time. Not to collect complaints about whoever came before. I want to know what it cost them, what they were told, and when they first suspected it was going wrong. The answers are specific and they change what I do next.
If the old system was never used, the question is not which features to add. It is why people went back to paper, and what would have to be true for them not to.
If the old build is a pile of changes nobody understands, the goal is not to copy it somewhere new. It is to work out which parts people rely on and leave the rest behind.
If the worry is cost that kept growing, then a small, clearly bounded first piece of work means more than any promise I can make.
I try not to answer the history with reassurance. "That won't happen with us" is exactly what the last person said. I would rather ask how they would like to check on progress, and what would make them comfortable stopping early if it isn't working.
People who have been burned ask better questions. I have come to like that. It keeps me from skating past the hard parts.